Composition

While the structured composition is not necessary for art, it can be a very dynamic component in creating two-dimensional art. We will explore some of the more traditional Western culture concepts in artistic composition. To understand compositional elements in a drawing or painting, you need to understand the fundamental framework and tools of composition that have evolved over the history of art. These structures and tools apply whether the subject is representational (from direct observation) or non-representational, which is termed "abstract."

Let us start with the basic idea of a dimensional flat surface; It has only an x-axis for height and a y-axis for width (Figure 1a). Any visual depth is an illusion created on a two-dimensional surface by a painting or drawing technique. This illusion of depth is the z-axis (Figure 1b).

Figure 1: Two-dimensional plane and three-dimensional illusion.

Comp_2D.jpg

(a) Two-dimensional plane x and the y-axis represent the canvas's surface or paper without depth (third dimension).

Comp_3D.jpg

(b) The third dimension, foreground to background, is represented by the z-axis. The paint or drawing techniques achieve the illusion of depth or a third dimension.

Understanding Compositional Tools, Structures, and Proportions

There are many compositional tools, structures, and proportions that artists can use when composing an image. The frameworks are very traditional and are used in classical paintings and contemporary artwork as well.

Compositional Tools: The compositional tool is a way to create the illusion of depth and movement and the optical path the artist would like the viewer to take—numerous tools are used in various combinations. The tools include vanishing-point perspective, two-point perspective, tone and value, color value, warm and cool colors, overlapping shapes and forms, and the size and scale of shapes and forms to indicate what is closest to the viewer and what is the farthest away, with varying degrees of distance in between.  
 
These compositional tools can move components of the art forward and back in the viewer's eye. This illusion of various components being closer (foreground) or further away (background) from the viewer is represented by the z-axis (Figure 1b).

 

Compositional Structure: Structure: Defining compositional structure as shapes such as the "S," Triangle, and the Circle; these shapes help define the organization of the picture and move the viewer's eye along the desired paths of the two-dimensional planes. Classical paintings and drawings use these basic structures/shapes (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Compositional structures.

Comp_Delacroix-S.jpg

(a) Eugene Delacroix , Odalisque, 1857.

Comp_Guerin.jpg

(b) Eugene Delacroix , Odalisque, 1857.

Comp_Matisse.jpg

(c) Henri Matisse,  Bathers with a Turtle, 1908.

Compositional Proportions and Object Placement: Proportions and Object Placement: Three systems come to mind: Golden Ratio, Fibonacci Spiral, and The Rule of Thirds.

Although the exact history of Phi, "The Golden Ratio," is not known, developed by the ancient Greeks in early mathematics before 500 B.C., Euclid (365 B.C.-300 B.C.) documented these proportions in his "Elements" text. (See Figure 3a.) The fantastic thing about these proportions is that they are throughout nature.
 
The Golden Ratio (also known as the Golden Mean) seems to have always been a compositional principle used by artists in design, painting, sculpture, and architecture throughout history.

 

Figure 3: Compositional proportions.

Comp_GoldenRule.jpg

a.  Golden Ratio or Golden Mean was developed by the Greeks in early mathematics, before 500 B.C.

Comp_FibonacciSpiral.jpg

b. Fibonacci Spiral

Comp_RuleOfThirds.jpg

c. Rule of Thirds

The Fibonacci Spiral (also known as the Golden Spiral) is closely related to the Golden Ratio. However, Fibonacci integrated another degree of elegance into the proportions. He found that Golden Ratio had the same mathematical properties as his math sequence: 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34, Etc. By dividing a rectangle with the square of its shorter side, the remaining rectangle has the exact ratio of 1:1.618. Moreover, if he divided that Triangle with the square based on its shorter side, the resulting Triangle is the same proportions as the previous rectangles, and so on, to infinity. Drawing an arc from one corner of each square resulted in a perfect spiral that would also be infinite. The Golden Spiral's mathematics and the resulting image are elegant and beautiful (Figure 3b).

The Fibonacci Spiral has been an essential compositional proportion artist have used since ancient times. An example of this spiral principle is the nautilus shell or a breaking ocean wave, to the proportions of how leaves and plants grow.

Another proportion and object placement system is The Rule of Thirds. The concept is to divide an image area into a grid using thirds horizontally and vertically (see Figure 3c). Placing the essential elements of composition at the intersections will create tension and interest, preferable to centering or less interesting placements. The Rule of Thirds is used less by painters and more often by photographers and filmmakers..

 

Master Artists' work for discussion and review for compositional elements

See if you can detect some of the compositional elements that have been discussed in the following artists' work. Some notations have been added to a few to help you see the structures. Now when you look at the artwork, whether it is a masterwork of art or a student's, see if you can determine what the artist is doing with the composition of the artwork.

Comp_AlHeld-.jpg

Al Held , Pisa II.

Comp_PaulCezanne_02.jpg
Comp_PaulCezanne_01.jpg

Paul Cézanne, Pommes et Oranges. This diagram on top of the painting shows the compositional element based on an "X" structure.

Comp_VasilyKandinsky.jpg

Vasily Kandinsky , Composition VIII.

Comp_RichardPousette-Dart.jpg

Richard Pousette-Dart ,  Symphony No. 1, The Transcendental

Comp_HansHofmann.jpg

Hans Hofmann, Combinable Wall I and II.

Comp_ClaudeMonet.jpg

Claude Monet , Impression, Soleil Levant.

Comp_ThomasWood.jpg

Thomas Peploe Wood - In his painting you can clearly see the use of the Fibonacci Spiral.